Mindy Kaling’s Scooby-Doo reboot achieves the impossible.

film It premiered on HBO Max last week, and almost immediately achieved the impossible feat of getting the internet to agree to something — and this attempt to embody Scooby DooThe most underrated character is very bad. Executive produced by and starring Mindy Kaling, one of the TV’s More controversial namesAnd film is an animated mystery for adults that follows teen Velma Dinkley as she tries to solve the mystery of the serial killings of her fellow high school students, as well as the biggest mystery that has plagued her: the disappearance of her mother.

film Intended to serve as an origin story, reverence for the film Homosexuality It is assumed that the brilliant Velma was in fact the one who brought together the Scooby Gang. Fred (Glenn Howerton), Daphne (Constance Wu), and Shaggy (voiced by Sam Richardson, referred to here by his stage name, Norville) are Velma’s classmates, ranging from sworn enemies to friends with wanted, unrequited feelings for a four-eye detective. But, like most original stories, it doesn’t work at all, despite boasting a track record The biggest premiere of an HBO Max animated seriesAnd film Sports is also one of them Lowest Rotten Tomatoes audience score ever seen.

As a person who loves animation Scooby The series, as well as live-action film adaptations of the cult favorite, originated the whole idea film It always looked ominous. For one, the original Scooby Iterations knew not to mess with the near-perfect formula: It was Self-awarenessAnd sarcasticAnd a lot funny. film, on the other hand, sits at the intersection of every easy way to implement streaming for a quick buck: rebooting the main IP, darkening the tone of the beloved kids’ franchise, trying to “wake up” old franchises, and so on. When properly balanced, these things can have great, even likable results — take Netflix last hit Wednesday, For example. But film Defaults at every stage of the process, starting with the justification for their existence.

I don’t need to feel represented. I want to be entertained.

The industry’s tendency to reboot tends to be to contradict who has the right to what. to filmThe legal victim is Scooby-Doo. Charlie Grundy, creator filmtestifies that he had always considered letting the dog out of the show as a way of getting older film More than that, but the option was solidified when Warner Bros. told them to do so. That dog was out of bounds due to licensing issues. a Scooby Doo A show without the dog seems pointless — why restart a comedy and then throw away its most inherently comedic elements?

In connection with other movements in the industry, I want to stop the notion that every historical white property or gang of characters needs to be dyed to fit today’s standards. I say this as someone who loves the race-swapped rebranding of a beloved series, and even enjoys the funniest White people got angry A fictional character that exists differently than they imagined. For me, one of the best things about the Scooby Gang that I grew up watching was how their whiteness tends to match a lot of their slang (the whitest words I’ve ever heard are “zoinks” and “jinkies” are probably the whitest words I’ve ever heard), characters, and decision-making joker. I didn’t need to feel represented by them so much as I wanted to entertain them. In this version, Velma is a narcissist who alienates everyone around her because she is a brown girl who is smarter than the rest and constantly reminds everyone of those two facts. It’s less comical and definitely less fun.

As for the show’s intent to satirize the liberal political climate via adult comedy, it’s incoherent enough to drive everyone crazy. Conservative critics They lost their minds upon learning that Velma would be openly lesbian, but the show also managed to alienate viewers who were against the series’ failed attempts at a more progressive approach. It’s true that Kaling has already been in the eyes of Internet leftists for a variety of transgressions, some arguable and others tense, ranging from self-loathing to Transphobia. But that’s also because of the show, in fact he Misogyny, and completely devoid of nuances. As Forbes points out, the show’s idea of ​​attacking white male privilege makes Fred “such a whiny white guy that his mother cuts his steak and he’s not done puberty until he has a small penis.” It totally sucks when Velma is forced to interact with her father’s pregnant friend Sophie (Melissa Fumero), a young white business owner who, despite being openly welcoming, is constantly denigrated by Velma as a stupid “basic whore.”

Ideally, “wokeness” isn’t something you perform, but a reality you choose to live in. When you force it, you end up with something that looks like a flashback to Twitter’s AI. filmAttempts to modernize the franchise are so inept that they have led to the emergence of Conspiracy theories which Kaling made intentionally film Bad as fodder for an ongoing culture war that people will constantly crave on the Internet. This criticism is his turn Conservatives claim Leftists are quick to classify anything they don’t like simply as “conservative.” Someone started a rumor that Scooby does not actually appear, but is personified by A.J A black female character named Scooby, angering those who thought the show would draw such a close parallel between a black woman and a dog. The actual character is named Gigi (Yvonne Orji), but even the rumor is out there Blame the conservativeswho are believed to have started it To piss off liberal viewers.

Of course, nothing is too ironic—it’s my opinion that even the best things in life deserve comic censure. But film It doesn’t feel like she’s intentionally and lovingly trying to poke fun at a political point of view, or anything else that identifies with it. It is almost impossible to understand Who is this offer. even still, filmTheir mistakes might be forgivable if they were at least funny. But it is not. Thus, we are left with a show where no one laughs and makes everyone angry, not even laughing wonderful song. To quote the Great Dane: spirits.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *